DETROIT (AP) — A Detroit-area man who was convicted of killing his first wife and whose second wife died under suspicious circumstances was granted an early release from prison after he argued that the risk of catching COVID-19 behind bars endangered his life.
Federal prosecutors fought to keep Roger Sweet locked up and were surprised by U.S. District Judge Victoria Roberts’ decision Friday. Investigators, too, were offended: Sweet hasn’t been cleared in the death of his second wife, whose remains were found in 2013, years after she disappeared.
“That’s crazy,” said Warren’s police commissioner, William Dwyer, who was involved in the investigation of the death of Sweet’s first wife, Marlene, in another community.
“The case involving the second wife is still open, that’s a cold case, and those cases are the type (police) don’t give up on,” Dwyer told The Detroit News.
Roberts ordered Sweet’s release even though he’s received a COVID-19 vaccine dose and survived a virus infection last year. She acknowledged that his crimes were “abhorrent” but said chronic health conditions, especially kidney disease, make him vulnerable.
“Without a single disciplinary action in 14 years of incarceration, Sweet’s behavior demonstrates a respect for the law and indicates how he may perform on supervised release,” Roberts said.
In 2008, Sweet was convicted in two Detroit-area courts and federal court. Those crimes included second-degree murder in the 1990 death of his first wife, the sexual assault of a 16-year-old girl and the sexual exploitation of children.
His federal prison sentence — 21 years — was the longest and still had seven years remaining, prosecutors said.
In 2007, Sweet’s second wife, Lizzie Mae Collier-Sweet, disappeared after a fire at their Brownstown Township home, south of Detroit, a blaze that triggered the criminal investigations.
Collier-Sweet’s remains were found in 2013 in a secluded area less than a mile away from the couple’s home. Her cause of death was listed as “indeterminate,” and no one has been charged.
After her disappearance, police said Collier-Sweet wrote in a diary that she feared her husband and slept on a couch with a hammer and shotgun, Assistant U.S. Attorney Kevin Mulcahy said in a court filing, citing news reports.
“Nothing about Sweet’s history and characteristics, which include rape, murder and the suspicious circumstances surrounding Lizzie Mae’s death, support releasing him early,” Mulcahy said.
A message seeking comment was left for the Brownstown Township police chief Tuesday.
Sweet will be confined to his home on electronic tether for 12 months with exceptions for work, religious services, medical appointments and court-ordered obligations, the judge said.