This April 2008 photo from the family of Kirby Brown shows the 38-year-old woman who died after being overcome in a sauna-like sweat lodge during a retreat (AP Photo).
This April 2008 photo from the family of Kirby Brown shows the 38-year-old woman who died after being overcome in a sauna-like sweat lodge during a retreat (AP Photo).
Updated: Monday, 12 Oct 2009, 10:52 PM EDT
Published : Monday, 12 Oct 2009, 10:50 PM EDT
FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. (AP) - A sweat lodge in central Arizona where two people were overcome
and later died lacked the necessary building permit, an official
said Monday.
Yavapai County building safety manager Jack Judd said there
was no record of an application or permit for a temporary structure
at the Angel Valley Retreat Center near Sedona.
At any one time, 55 to 65 people attending the "Spiritual
Warrior" program hosted by self-help expert and author James Arthur
Ray were crowded into the 415-square-foot space during a two-hour
period Thursday night, Yavapai County sheriff's officials said.
Kirby Brown, 38, of Westtown, N.Y., and James Shore, 40, of
Milwaukee died after being overcome in the sauna-like hut, which
was built specifically for the five-day retreat. Nineteen other
people were hospitalized with symptoms ranging from dehydration to
kidney failure. One remained in critical condition Monday, and two
others were in fair condition.
Sheriff's spokesman Dwight D'Evelyn said authorities believe
Ray's staff either participated in erecting the structure or
oversaw the construction. Ray's spokesman, Howard Bragman, declined
to comment on the permit but said the resort's staff was under
contract to build a sweat lodge to accommodate up to 75 people.
Resort owners Amayra and Michael Hamilton did not immediately
return calls to their home and the resort Monday. However, Amayra
Hamilton said Saturday the sweat lodge, which was built with a wood
frame and covered with layers of tarps and blankets, had been taken
down.
Judd said no inspection of the structure was conducted before
it was dismantled.
Verde Valley Fire Chief Jerry Doerksen, whose department
responded to the initial 911 call of two people not breathing, said
his department regularly inspects the Hamiltons' property. He said
the couple never hesitates to ask questions, raise concerns or
address issues brought up by fire officials.
An inspection of the fire area used to heat the
cantaloupe-sized rocks that were taken into the sweat lodge
determined it "would have been a legal fire," Doerksen said.
"Where they had the fire, they had a big area outside of it
that was cleared," he said. "There wasn't a risk of it spreading
someplace."
The sheriff's office is investigating to determine if
criminal negligence played a role in the deaths or illnesses. Tests
for contaminants ruled out carbon monoxide poisoning as a cause.
Autopsies on Brown and Shore were conducted, but the results
are being withheld pending additional tests.
Sweat lodges -- used by American Indian tribes to cleanse the
body and prepare for hunts, ceremonies and other events -- are a
common practice in the area. Most are on private property and hold
no more than a dozen people, Doerksen said.
Large-scale sweat lodges appear to create a "new challenge
for us," he said.
Talks are planned between his department and county officials
to consider issuing health warnings for events such as sweat lodges
that would include suggestions on how long to stay in.
"It's the same with hot tubs and saunas," Doerksen said.
"Most of the time in a motel, it will say do not stay in there more
than 10 to 15 minutes. What we're looking at is the same kind of
thing."