Bobby Fisk_20100120172148_JPG

Bobby Fisk is on trial for murdering Robert and Norma Bean in October 2008 (Jan. 20, 2010)

bobby-fisk-murder-trial-a-0_20100120121436_JPG

Testimony began at the trial of Bobby Fisk, accused of murdering Norma and Robert Bean in Oct. 2008 (Jan. 20, 2010)

Norma and Robert Bean_20100119105612_JPG

Norma and Robert Bean (file photo)

  • The Howard City murders - other stories
New trial denied in Howard City murder
New trial denied in Howard City murder

Bobby Fisk, who was convicted in 2010 of kidnapping and …

Fisk sentenced for Howard City murders
Fisk sentenced for Howard City murders

Robert Fisk will spend the rest of his life in prison for …

Fisk guilty in couple's murder
Fisk guilty in couple's murder

Bobby Fisk has been found guilty of first-degree murder in the …

Fisk case in jury's hands
Fisk case in jury's hands

The jury began deliberating whether Robert Fisk is guilty or …

Bobby Fisk testifies in own defense
Bobby Fisk testifies in own defense

Minutes after his lawyer told the court he wouldn't call any …

Detective:Fisk kept changing stories
Detective:Fisk kept changing stories

Inconsistencies in his story led police to believe Robert Fisk …

At Fisk murder trial, CSIs take stand
At Fisk murder trial, CSIs take stand

The scene where the bodies of Norma and Robert Bean were found …

Fisk trial: from witness to suspect
Fisk trial: from witness to suspect

The second day of testimony in Bobby Fisk's murder trial may …

Witnesses testify at Fisk murder trial
Witnesses testify at Fisk murder trial

The murder trial began Wednesday for Bobby Fisk, accused of …

Man admits murdering Howard City couple
Man admits murdering Howard City couple

One of the men accused in the kidnapping and murder of a Howard…

Pair reject deal in Howard City murders
Pair reject deal in Howard City murders

Two men accused of killing a Howard City couple rejected a plea…

Howard City murder suspects to trial
Howard City murder suspects to trial

Two men accused of robbing, kidnapping and then killing a …

Pair arraigned in Howard City murders
Men charged in Howard City murders

Bobby Fisk and Tim Stephan were arraigned by video, each facing…

Advertisement

Fisk case in jury's hands

Deliberations underway in murder trial

Updated: Friday, 29 Jan 2010, 12:21 PM EST
Published : Thursday, 28 Jan 2010, 10:37 AM EST

GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (WOOD) - The jury began deliberating whether Robert Fisk is guilty or not guilty of murdering Norma and Robert Bean, after a day that began with Fisk testifying he didn't kill the Howard City couple.

Fisk took the stand Wednesday and claimed Tim Stephan - who has already been sentenced to life in prison for the murders of Norma and Robert Bean of Howard City - pressured him into killing Norma Bean.

But when closing arguments began, Judge Dennis Leiber ruled duress cannot be used as a defense in this case. However, defense attorney Damian Nunzio can still argue Stephan threatened to kill Fisk if Fisk didn't go through with the crime.

Prosecutor Helen Brinkman said that every case is a puzzle, and when the pieces are put together, the picture will point to Fisk being a killer. She said the Beans were targeted for money because they owned a business. And, she said, Stephan was not he mastermind. This crime's MO is Fisk's.

Brinkman reminded the jury what Robert Bean said just before he was shot to death. "You said you wouldn't shoot (Norma,)" he was quoted as saying. That, Brinkman said, is proof the murders were planned.

When Nunzio began his closing argument, he asked the jury if Fisk masterminded the crime, why didn't he have anything from the robbery to show for it?

Shortly after noon, Leiber gave the jury their instructions. They picked a foreperson and began deliberations. But they wanted to see some of the evidence.

The jury asked the judge to review the 911 call Fisk made after he left the scene where the Beans' bodies were found, and a video tape from inside the police car that was taking Fisk to the county jail for questioning.

On the tape, Fisk is seen pulling something out of his pocket. Detectives say it was a mask Fisk used to cover his face when he helped rob, kidnap and kill the Beans.

The jury will look at that evidence when they reconvene Friday morning.

Follow the trial through Joe LaFurgey's tweets .

  • Comments
Opinions that are derogatory, attack other users, offer unsubstantiated facts or are offensive in nature can and will be removed as defined by the Terms of Service. WOOD is not responsible for the content posted in this comment section. We reserve the right to remove any offensive or off-topic remark or thread. To mark a comment for review by a moderator, click "Report."
Advertisement
  • Must See Video
Advertisement